What owners found when they checked.
Rental owners on their own property managers, in their own words.
- Maintenance eats the rent. 5 weeks later I get a bill from them for a couple thousand bucks. 'That's weird' I think, 'I'm supposed to be receiving money, not paying it'. Rental owner.
- Maintenance eats the rent. Rent is collected on time, but instead of seeing cash flow, it's constantly absorbed by "maintenance" and "reserve replenishment" charges. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. They keep making charges to appease the tenant and just this month alone they charged $800 in repairs including fixing a fan blade and replaced an outlet cover in the bed room. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. They sent a guy out 3 times then replaced a year old dishwasher. Over $1500 and it still didn't work. ... I had spent 1500 for a $20 fix. Never again. Rental owner.
- Money gone missing. Almost an entire year of gross rent was lost, -$45k to that thieving PM company. ... Felt like I was in a choke hold for 12 months. Rental owner.
- Rent held back. My property manager in Austin, Texas took my renters monthly rent and never paid me out. ... His business has folded and he blocked my number and email. Rental owner, Austin, Texas.
- Money gone missing. Personally I lost $40k between rent, and projects I paid for that PM never paid the contractor. PM went to jail, and I didn't get a dime back. Rental owner, Cleveland, Ohio.
- Money gone missing. Had a property management company that was skimming and co-mingling funds. Hiding balances using fake contractor invoices and kept changing reserve requirements. Rental owner.
- Maintenance eats the rent. We know the property management company is taking kickbacks. We've not gotten a full deposit yet. Monthly maintenance charges are $400-$500!!! We are losing money every month. Rental owner.
- Money gone missing. We actually had a PM for a few MD rentals rip us off for about $60,000 then file bankruptcy and ghost us. Rental owner, Pennsylvania.
- Big bill, small fix. They charged $168 for a water heater flush ... and $480 for a "touch up" cleaning done a few weeks after a professional move out clean. Rental owner, Arizona.
- Billed for work not done. I got charged for someone cutting the grass every 3 days ... (the gardener was not even performing the work) Rental owner.
- Rent held back. They were fine until he stopped paying me. Kept making excuses- like 4 months without money Rental owner.
- Billed for work not done. I'll never hire a PM again. ... They did none of it and charged me for the work. Rental owner.
- Maintenance eats the rent. I've had a PM who basically spent all the rent on improvements or repairs that he thought were required through using his "crew" Rental owner.
- Done without approval. They frequently authorize and charge repairs without approval - even after I've asked that all work be cleared with me first. Rental owner.
- Billed for work not done. It was terrible. They didn't respond to most tenants, they kept maintenance issues from us, charges for cleaning/yard work that never happened Rental owner.
- Money gone missing. She took $4500 from the renter and ghosted me. She was only authorized to take $3500. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. Then they charged $80/hour for any repairs, called in licensed professionals for simple stuff like setting toilets. ... Anyway, it came out to about 33k per year. Rental owner.
- Rent held back. Monies due us delayed by up to 3 months. ... Multiple calls...ignored. Attorneys involved...again, ignored. Rental owner.
- Rent held back. I've followed up multiple times, and they keep apologizing and saying accounting is working on it. but I still haven't received the money or a clear explanation or payment date. Rental owner, Detroit, Michigan.
- Maintenance eats the rent. The management agreement allows them to handle repairs under $275 without our approval, and we were repeatedly receiving reduced owner disbursements because of repairs. Rental owner, Texas.
- Kept in the dark. I asked them if they could reach out to me if something is needed and they said "no." So I am realizing they can just continually burn through money. Rental owner, Arizona.
- Big bill, small fix. They were sleeping and the relatively new ceiling fan magically broke. $500. Rental owner.
- Rent held back. He started out good, but got overly sloppy with time, nickle-and-dimed me for everything, hired his buddies who cut corners on repairs ... and was always late to send me the rent he collected. Rental owner.
- Done without approval. AND the PM company tried to charge me for the refinishing that I never approved. Rental owner.
- Kept in the dark. ... $1,000 combined sewer water bill for an empty property that they didn't catch. Also we were robbed and they didn't know anything about it. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. My New Orleans manager also upcharges any repair 10%. ... It's $100 to pull up in the driveway of either house in New Orleans Rental owner, New Orleans, LA.
- Kept in the dark. I've had PMs fail to tell me a tenant left the property. Had an empty property and didn't know it until next rent didn't show up. Rental owner.
- Kept in the dark. Had a property manager for an out of state Airbnb who rented it without telling me. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. I thought they'd get great contractor pricing, but simple repairs are at insanely high rates. ... Nothing but a nightmare since. Rental owner.
- Kept in the dark. Our relationship has become tense since we keep calling for clarification on repairs that were made that we were not aware of. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. Price gouging small repairs and doing the bare minimum with multiple different PM's. Makes me want to self manage Rental owner.
- Burned by a PM. no need for prop manager. tried that for 3 years. nearly went bankrupt. never again. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. We had a property manager who was paying handymen $100 bucks to drive from several towns over when the town our properties are in is replete with repairmen. Rental owner.
- Burned by a PM. Bad property managers can ruin you financially. ... All at my expense. Cost me so much money. Rental owner.
- Kept in the dark. my calls to the county re: progress on the eviction reveals the PM has been lying about actions they've taken and the timeline in which these things have happened. Rental owner.
- Big bill, small fix. When I asked for the quotes, it took them forever to do so, and they were very expensive. I ended up traveling to PA to fix stuff myself Rental owner, NYC.
- Kept in the dark. month 3 tenant late again, doesn't tell me, I have to reach out and ask where rent is Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. After tenants moved out, I had over 9k in property damage that could and should have been prevented strictly from a neglectful PM. Rental owner.
- Kept in the dark. My husband went to the property today and the grass was TWO FEET HIGH. They said they had a showing last week. Rental owner, Baltimore, Maryland.
- Tenants mishandled. They had the audacity to ask for their security deposit back and to this day owe me like seven grand ... All based on the PM's recommendation of a "good tenant" they found for me Rental owner.
- Managing the manager. Cost us so much money and frustration managing the management! Why are we paying u if i have to keep reminding u of simple things? Rental owner, Baltimore, Maryland.
- Done without approval. They also transferred all the bills on their name without my approval Rental owner, NYC.
- Repairs ignored. My former PM basically made me a slum lord. Would send "her guy" for maintenance issues 3 months after requested Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. The PM had a personal friend with low 600 fico he was trying to help out using my property Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. I had to fire my most recent PM. ... The new company neglected my tenants, didn't answer emails and broke so many laws I deemed them a liability. Rental owner.
- Burned by a PM. For the first five or six years I had property managers. They screwed me over real bad. Rental owner, Hawaii.
- Kept in the dark. We have also requested the move-in and move-out inspection reports, but there has been no response for over 10 days now. Rental owner, Texas.
- Repairs ignored. That's how I found out my property manager had been ignoring their maintenance requests. I fired my property manager after I found out about that Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. Then we found out that they called references but if the reference didn't answer, they treated it the same as a good reference. I was stunned they would be so sloppy Rental owner.
- Repairs ignored. once i started managing myself I really saw how neglectful he actually was. ... With a PM you're on a hamster wheel of problems, never getting any of them resolved. Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. they have been working with a notoriously late tenant in my duplex who is now 2 months behind. ... they never put all the pieces together to come to that conclusion. Rental owner.
- Tenants mishandled. I have had a good manager and I have had a bad one (200k house in Florida 1000 miles away from me). ... The bad one rented to a deadbeat and created havoc. Rental owner, Florida.
- Kept in the dark. Not knowing exactly what's going on at any time. Rental owner, New Orleans, LA.
- Burned by a PM. I was underwhelmed to say the least. They were mostly acting in their own interests and didn't give it nearly the time and attention that I do. Rental owner, California.
- Managing the manager. I find myself being very tempted to micromanage this person because I just feel like they are forgetting to do things, or not doing them well. Rental owner.
- Burned by a PM. I hired a PM for my first rental out of the gate and it was the worst decision I've made with my rental. Rental owner.
- Burned by a PM. In theory, Property management should alleviate the stress, but we've found it to be the opposite. Rental owner, Pennsylvania.
- Tenants mishandled. I felt like they ran off good tenants by not managing things well. Rental owner.
- Managing the manager. Also a PM isn't going to solve all of your problems- I've found that I often have to manage the property manager. Rental owner.
- Managing the manager. Instead I have to identify all these things myself then ask the PM to do them regularly; and forget them remembering themselves to do it - I have to remind every year! Rental owner.
Real owners, in their own words. Names left out to protect them.
Plenty of property managers do honest work. Checking is how you know yours does.
Six charges owners found, in dollars.
Each line is one owner's own story, with the amounts as they wrote them.
| What it was | In the owner's story |
|---|---|
| Work over the approval limit, without asking | A $6,700 invoice. The agreement said to ask first for anything over $600.Oregon, 2023 |
| A cost that grew after the yes | A door approved at $550. Then a new bill for about $1,500 more.2024 |
| An hourly charge on top of the monthly fee | $364 for getting an electrician to give a quote.Michigan, 2020 |
| A cut taken on the labor | $50 an hour charged for maintenance. The contractor was paid $35.Connecticut, 2024 |
| A quote at twice the owner's own | $400 quoted for one pest control visit. The owner's own quote was $200.Maryland, 2022 |
| The same repair, paid for again | Over $600 in a year on one leak, reported three times and never fixed.2026 |
The state is shown where the owner gave one.
Wondering about your own statement?
Bring one. Leave with a plain answer.
Your first check is free.